Files
litellm/tests/spend_tracking_tests/test_spend_accuracy_tests.py
T
Mateo WangandGitHub 2c733c00f5 chore(ci): modernize model references in tests and configs (#27856)
* test: modernize models used in CircleCI e2e test suites

Replaces obsolete models (gpt-4o, gpt-4o-mini, gpt-3.5-turbo,
claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620, claude-sonnet-4-20250514) with current
equivalents across the e2e_openai_endpoints and
proxy_e2e_anthropic_messages_tests CircleCI jobs.

- gpt-4o -> gpt-5.5 (responses API e2e tests)
- gpt-4o-mini -> gpt-5-mini (websocket responses, oai_misc_config)
- gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18 -> gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14 (fine-tuning,
  still actively fine-tunable)
- gpt-4 / gpt-3.5-turbo target_model_names example -> gpt-5.5 /
  gpt-5-mini
- bedrock claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620 batch entry -> haiku-4-5-20251001
  (also aligning oai_misc_config model_name with what
  test_bedrock_batches_api.py actually requests)
- bedrock claude-sonnet-4-20250514 (deprecated, retires 2026-06-15)
  -> claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929

* test: point bedrock-claude-sonnet-4 alias at Sonnet 4.6, not 4.5

Greptile/Cursor flagged that after the previous commit, the
bedrock-claude-sonnet-4 alias collided with bedrock-claude-sonnet-4.5
(both pointed to claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929). Rename to
bedrock-claude-sonnet-4.6 and point it at the Sonnet 4.6 Bedrock ID
(us.anthropic.claude-sonnet-4-6, already in the litellm model
registry) so the alias name matches the underlying model version.

* test: modernize models across remaining CI-mounted configs & tests

Expands the modernization sweep to all CircleCI-mounted proxy configs
and to test directories where the model literal is a fixture/route key
(not the test's subject).

Config changes:
- proxy_server_config.yaml: bump gpt-3.5-turbo / gpt-3.5-turbo-1106 /
  gpt-4o / gemini-1.5-flash / dall-e-3 underlying models; rename
  gpt-3.5-turbo-end-user-test alias to gpt-5-mini-end-user-test; bump
  text-embedding-ada-002 underlying to text-embedding-3-small. User-
  facing aliases (gpt-3.5-turbo, gpt-4, text-embedding-ada-002, etc.)
  preserved for backward compatibility with tests.
- simple_config.yaml, otel_test_config.yaml, spend_tracking_config.yaml:
  bump gpt-3.5-turbo underlying to gpt-5-mini.
- pass_through_config.yaml: claude-3-5-sonnet / claude-3-7-sonnet /
  claude-3-haiku entries replaced with claude-sonnet-4-5 / claude-
  haiku-4-5 / claude-opus-4-7.
- oai_misc_config.yaml: align alias name with the gpt-5-mini rename.

Test changes (proactive: claude-sonnet-4-20250514 / claude-opus-4-
20250514 retire 2026-06-15):
- tests/llm_translation/test_anthropic_completion.py: bump 3 references
  + paired Vertex AI ID to claude-sonnet-4-5.
- tests/llm_translation/test_optional_params.py: bump 2 references.
- tests/pass_through_unit_tests/test_anthropic_messages_passthrough.py
  and test_bedrock_anthropic_messages_test.py: bump router fixtures
  using the deprecated model IDs.
- tests/pass_through_unit_tests/base_anthropic_messages_tool_search_test.py:
  modernize docstring examples.
- tests/test_end_users.py: update references to renamed alias.

* test: modernize placeholder model literals in router_unit_tests

Mass replace_all on fixture/placeholder model literals across the
router_unit_tests/ suite (model name is a routing key / label, not the
test subject). Sub-agent sweep so far — additional commits will follow
for logging_callback_tests/, enterprise/, top-level tests/test_*.py,
and other CI-mounted dirs.

Mappings applied:
- gpt-3.5-turbo -> gpt-5-mini
- gpt-4 (bare) -> gpt-5.5
- gpt-4o (bare) -> gpt-5
- text-embedding-ada-002 -> text-embedding-3-small
- claude-3-sonnet-20240229 / claude-3-opus-20240229 /
  claude-3-haiku-20240307 / claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620 ->
  claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929 / claude-opus-4-7 /
  claude-haiku-4-5-20251001 as appropriate

Explicitly preserved:
- gpt-4o-mini-* variants (transcribe, tts, etc.) where they're current
- gpt-4-turbo / gpt-4-vision-preview / gpt-4-0613 (subject literals)
- JSONL batch body literals
- Mock LLM response model fields (must match upstream)
- Fake/mock identifiers

* test: modernize placeholder model literals across remaining CI suites

Sub-agent sweep across logging_callback_tests/, guardrails_tests/,
enterprise/, pass_through_unit_tests/, otel_tests/,
llm_responses_api_testing/, batches_tests/, spend_tracking_tests/,
litellm_utils_tests/, unified_google_tests/, and a few top-level
tests/test_*.py files where the model literal is a fixture or
placeholder (router model_list, mock standard logging payload, mock
callback data) rather than the test's subject.

Mappings applied (see scope notes below):
- gpt-3.5-turbo -> gpt-5-mini
- gpt-4 (bare) -> gpt-5.5
- gpt-4o (bare) -> gpt-5.5 (corrected from initial gpt-5 — bare gpt-5
  is not a valid OpenAI alias; only gpt-5.5 / gpt-5.4 / gpt-5.2-codex
  / gpt-5-mini exist)
- gpt-4o-mini (bare) -> gpt-5-mini
- text-embedding-ada-002 -> text-embedding-3-small
- claude-3-sonnet-20240229 -> claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
- claude-3-opus-20240229 -> claude-opus-4-7
- claude-3-haiku-20240307 -> claude-haiku-4-5-20251001
- claude-3-5-sonnet-20240620/20241022 -> claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929
- claude-3-7-sonnet-20250219 -> claude-sonnet-4-6
- gemini-1.5-flash -> gemini-2.5-flash
- gemini-1.5-pro -> gemini-2.5-pro

Explicitly preserved (not modernized):
- llm_translation/ tests where model is the SUBJECT (provider-specific
  translation/transformation logic). Only the deprecated 20250514
  references were already bumped in a prior commit.
- Cost-calc / tokenizer subject tests in test_utils.py (skip-ranges
  documented by the sub-agent).
- Bedrock model IDs in test_health_check.py path-stripping tests.
- JSONL batch request bodies and mock LLM response bodies (must match
  upstream literal).
- Langfuse expected-request-body JSON fixtures (cost values are exact-
  match-asserted; changing the model would shift response_cost).
- gpt-3.5-turbo-instruct (text-completion endpoint; no modern OpenAI
  equivalent).
- Top-level tests calling the proxy through user-facing aliases
  (gpt-3.5-turbo, gpt-4, text-embedding-ada-002, dall-e-3) — aliases
  in proxy_server_config.yaml stay; only the underlying model was
  bumped.
- tests/test_gpt5_azure_temperature_support.py (the test's whole point
  is model-name handling).
- Fake / mock / openai/fake identifiers.

Notable side fixes:
- test_spend_accuracy_tests.py: UPSTREAM_MODEL now matches what
  spend_tracking_config.yaml's proxy actually routes to (gpt-5-mini),
  resolving a latent inconsistency.
- proxy_server_config.yaml: bare `gpt-5` alias renamed to `gpt-5.5`
  (bare gpt-5 is not a valid OpenAI alias).
- test_batches_logging_unit_tests.py: explicit_models list entries
  kept distinct (gpt-5-mini + gpt-5.5) after bulk rename.

* test: fix CI failures from model modernization sweep

CI surfaced 4 categories of regression from the bulk modernization:

1. Azure deployment names are customer-specific. Reverted:
   - tests/litellm_utils_tests/test_health_check.py: azure/text-
     embedding-3-small -> azure/text-embedding-ada-002 (the CI Azure
     account does not have a text-embedding-3-small deployment).
   - tests/logging_callback_tests/test_custom_callback_router.py:
     same revert for two router fixtures driving aembedding.

2. gpt-5 family does not accept temperature != 1. Tests that pass a
   custom temperature swapped from gpt-5-mini to gpt-4.1-mini (modern
   non-reasoning OpenAI mini that still accepts temperature/logprobs):
   - tests/logging_callback_tests/test_datadog.py
   - tests/logging_callback_tests/test_langsmith_unit_test.py
   - tests/logging_callback_tests/test_otel_logging.py

3. proxy_server_config.yaml's gpt-3.5-turbo-large alias was routing to
   gpt-5.5 (a reasoning model that rejects logprobs). The proxy test
   tests/test_openai_endpoints.py::test_chat_completion_streaming
   exercises logprobs/top_logprobs through that alias. Bumped the
   underlying model to gpt-4.1 (non-reasoning, still modern).

4. tests/logging_callback_tests/test_gcs_pub_sub.py asserts against a
   pinned JSON fixture (gcs_pub_sub_body/spend_logs_payload.json) with
   hardcoded model="gpt-4o" and a model-specific spend value. Reverted
   the litellm.acompletion calls in the test to model="gpt-4o" so the
   fixture's exact-match assertions still hold.

5. tests/pass_through_unit_tests/test_anthropic_messages_passthrough.py:
   anthropic.messages.create routing to openai/gpt-5-mini returned an
   empty content[0] with max_tokens=100 (reasoning-token consumption).
   Swapped to openai/gpt-4.1-mini.

* test: fix Assistants API model + 2 cursor[bot] review nits

1. pass_through_unit_tests/test_custom_logger_passthrough.py: gpt-5.5
   isn't accepted by the /v1/assistants endpoint
   ("unsupported_model"). Switch to gpt-4.1-mini (modern, Assistants-
   API-supported, non-reasoning).

2. example_config_yaml/pass_through_config.yaml: the previous sweep
   bumped the claude-3-7-sonnet alias to claude-opus-4-7, which is a
   tier change (Sonnet -> Opus). Map to claude-sonnet-4-6 to keep the
   Sonnet tier intact. (Cursor bugbot review.)

3. example_config_yaml/simple_config.yaml: model_name was left as
   gpt-3.5-turbo while the underlying was bumped to gpt-5-mini, which
   muddles the "simple" example. Make both sides gpt-5-mini so the
   most basic example is a straight 1:1 mapping again. (Cursor bugbot
   review.)

* fix: revert gpt-4/gpt-3.5-turbo alias underlying to non-reasoning models

tests/test_openai_endpoints.py::test_completion calls the proxy alias
"gpt-4" with temperature=0, and other tests call gpt-3.5-turbo with
custom temperature / logprobs / the legacy /v1/completions endpoint.
The earlier modernization mapped both aliases to gpt-5.5 / gpt-5-mini,
which are reasoning models that reject temperature != 1 and don't
expose /v1/completions. Map the aliases to gpt-4.1 / gpt-4.1-mini
(modern non-reasoning OpenAI models) instead — keeps user-facing
aliases preserved while picking a current underlying that still
supports the parameters/endpoints the tests exercise.
2026-05-15 15:44:28 -07:00

396 lines
16 KiB
Python

import pytest
import asyncio
import aiohttp
import time
import litellm
from litellm._uuid import uuid
"""
Tests to run
Basic Tests:
1. Basic Spend Accuracy Test:
- Make N requests, compute expected total spend locally from each response's usage
- Poll until batch writer has flushed spend to the DB
- Expect spend for Key, Team, User, Org (/info endpoints) to equal the computed total
2. Long term spend accuracy test (with 2 bursts of requests)
- Burst 1: compute expected from responses, verify
- Burst 2: compute expected from responses, verify total = burst1 + burst2
Additional Test Scenarios:
3. Concurrent Request Accuracy Test:
- Make 20 concurrent requests
- Check for race conditions in spend tracking
4. Error Case Test:
- Make 10 successful requests
- Make 5 failed requests
- Verify spend is only counted for successful requests
5. Mixed Request Type Test:
- Make different types of requests with varying costs
- Verify accurate total spend calculation
"""
# Upstream model the proxy is configured with (spend_tracking_config.yaml).
# The proxy computes spend using this model's pricing; the local ground-truth
# calculation uses the same pricing table via litellm.cost_per_token.
UPSTREAM_MODEL = "gpt-5-mini"
# Batch writer flush cadence in CI is ~2-7s (PROXY_BATCH_WRITE_AT=2 + up to 5s jitter).
# Poll every 2s for 60s — plenty of headroom for multiple ticks to land.
POLL_INTERVAL_SECONDS = 2
POLL_TIMEOUT_SECONDS = 60
TOLERANCE = 1e-10
def _make_test_session() -> aiohttp.ClientSession:
"""
Session tuned for CI reliability:
- force_close: avoid aiohttp reusing a TCP connection that the proxy/kernel
silently closed during the long idle window between setup POSTs and the
later poll loop (observed failure mode: ConnectionTimeoutError on the
first /key/info call after 20 chat completions).
- explicit connect timeout: surface a blocked proxy event loop quickly
instead of hanging on aiohttp's 5-minute default total timeout.
"""
return aiohttp.ClientSession(
connector=aiohttp.TCPConnector(force_close=True),
timeout=aiohttp.ClientTimeout(total=30, connect=10),
)
async def create_organization(session, organization_alias: str):
"""Helper function to create a new organization"""
url = "http://0.0.0.0:4000/organization/new"
headers = {"Authorization": "Bearer sk-1234", "Content-Type": "application/json"}
data = {"organization_alias": organization_alias}
async with session.post(url, headers=headers, json=data) as response:
return await response.json()
async def create_team(session, org_id: str):
"""Helper function to create a new team under an organization"""
url = "http://0.0.0.0:4000/team/new"
headers = {"Authorization": "Bearer sk-1234", "Content-Type": "application/json"}
data = {"organization_id": org_id, "team_alias": f"test-team-{uuid.uuid4()}"}
async with session.post(url, headers=headers, json=data) as response:
return await response.json()
async def create_user(session, org_id: str):
"""Helper function to create a new user"""
url = "http://0.0.0.0:4000/user/new"
headers = {"Authorization": "Bearer sk-1234", "Content-Type": "application/json"}
data = {"user_name": f"test-user-{uuid.uuid4()}"}
async with session.post(url, headers=headers, json=data) as response:
return await response.json()
async def generate_key(session, user_id: str, team_id: str):
"""Helper function to generate a key for a specific user and team"""
url = "http://0.0.0.0:4000/key/generate"
headers = {"Authorization": "Bearer sk-1234", "Content-Type": "application/json"}
data = {"user_id": user_id, "team_id": team_id}
async with session.post(url, headers=headers, json=data) as response:
return await response.json()
async def chat_completion(session, key: str):
"""Make a chat completion request"""
from openai import AsyncOpenAI
from litellm._uuid import uuid
client = AsyncOpenAI(api_key=key, base_url="http://0.0.0.0:4000/v1")
response = await client.chat.completions.create(
model="fake-openai-endpoint",
messages=[{"role": "user", "content": f"Test message {uuid.uuid4()}"}],
)
return response
async def get_spend_info(session, entity_type: str, entity_id: str):
"""Helper function to get spend information for an entity"""
url = f"http://0.0.0.0:4000/{entity_type}/info"
headers = {"Authorization": "Bearer sk-1234", "Content-Type": "application/json"}
if entity_type == "key":
data = {"key": entity_id}
else:
data = {f"{entity_type}_id": entity_id}
async with session.get(url, headers=headers, params=data) as response:
return await response.json()
async def get_proxy_readiness(session):
"""Fetch authenticated readiness details. Used both as a fail-fast gate and as a diagnostic on poll timeout."""
url = "http://0.0.0.0:4000/health/readiness/details"
headers = {"Authorization": "Bearer sk-1234"}
async with session.get(url, headers=headers) as response:
return response.status, await response.json()
async def assert_proxy_healthy(session):
"""Fail fast if the proxy's DB or cache is not reachable — no point running the test."""
status, body = await get_proxy_readiness(session)
if status != 200 or body.get("db") != "connected":
pytest.fail(
f"Proxy /health/readiness/details unhealthy (status={status}). "
f"Cannot run spend accuracy test. Response: {body}"
)
print(f"Proxy readiness OK: {body}")
def compute_expected_spend(responses) -> float:
"""
Compute the expected total spend locally from each response's usage tokens,
using the same pricing table the proxy uses. This is the independent ground
truth we compare the proxy's reported spend against.
"""
total = 0.0
for r in responses:
usage = r.usage
prompt_cost, completion_cost = litellm.cost_per_token(
model=UPSTREAM_MODEL,
prompt_tokens=usage.prompt_tokens,
completion_tokens=usage.completion_tokens,
)
total += prompt_cost + completion_cost
return total
async def poll_key_spend_until(session, key: str, expected: float) -> float:
"""
Poll key spend until it matches `expected` within TOLERANCE, or timeout.
Returns the last observed spend either way; caller decides how to report.
"""
start = time.time()
last_spend = 0.0
while time.time() - start < POLL_TIMEOUT_SECONDS:
try:
key_info = await get_spend_info(session, "key", key)
except (aiohttp.ClientError, asyncio.TimeoutError) as exc:
print(
f"Transient transport error during spend poll: "
f"{type(exc).__name__}: {exc}. Retrying... "
f"({time.time() - start:.1f}s elapsed)"
)
await asyncio.sleep(POLL_INTERVAL_SECONDS)
continue
last_spend = key_info["info"]["spend"]
if abs(last_spend - expected) < TOLERANCE:
print(
f"Key spend reached expected {expected} after {time.time() - start:.1f}s"
)
return last_spend
print(
f"Key spend {last_spend}, expected {expected}, waiting... "
f"({time.time() - start:.1f}s elapsed)"
)
await asyncio.sleep(POLL_INTERVAL_SECONDS)
return last_spend
async def fail_with_diagnostics(session, stage: str, expected: float, observed: float):
"""Emit a failure with readiness state so CI output points at the real cause."""
_, readiness = await get_proxy_readiness(session)
pytest.fail(
f"{stage}: key spend did not match expected after {POLL_TIMEOUT_SECONDS}s poll. "
f"expected={expected}, observed={observed}, diff={expected - observed}. "
f"Proxy readiness: {readiness}"
)
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_basic_spend_accuracy():
"""
Test basic spend accuracy across different entities:
1. Create org, team, user, and key
2. Make N requests, keeping each response
3. Compute expected spend locally from response usage (independent ground truth)
4. Poll until proxy-reported spend matches expected
5. Verify spend is consistent across key, team, user, and org entities
"""
NUM_LLM_REQUESTS = 20
async with _make_test_session() as session:
await assert_proxy_healthy(session)
org_response = await create_organization(
session=session, organization_alias=f"test-org-{uuid.uuid4()}"
)
print("org_response: ", org_response)
org_id = org_response["organization_id"]
team_response = await create_team(session, org_id)
print("team_response: ", team_response)
team_id = team_response["team_id"]
user_response = await create_user(session, org_id)
print("user_response: ", user_response)
user_id = user_response["user_id"]
key_response = await generate_key(session, user_id, team_id)
print("key_response: ", key_response)
key = key_response["key"]
responses = []
for i in range(NUM_LLM_REQUESTS):
response = await chat_completion(session, key)
responses.append(response)
print(f"Request {i + 1}/{NUM_LLM_REQUESTS} completed")
expected_spend = compute_expected_spend(responses)
assert expected_spend > 0, (
f"Locally computed expected spend is {expected_spend}. Either cost calc "
f"is broken or upstream returned zero tokens. "
f"Usage: {[r.usage.model_dump() for r in responses]}"
)
print(f"Expected total spend (local ground truth): {expected_spend}")
final_spend = await poll_key_spend_until(session, key, expected_spend)
if abs(final_spend - expected_spend) >= TOLERANCE:
await fail_with_diagnostics(
session,
stage="test_basic_spend_accuracy",
expected=expected_spend,
observed=final_spend,
)
# Allow a final scheduler tick for team/user/org aggregations to settle
await asyncio.sleep(5)
key_info = await get_spend_info(session, "key", key)
print("key_info: ", key_info)
team_info = await get_spend_info(session, "team", team_id)
print("team_info: ", team_info)
user_info = await get_spend_info(session, "user", user_id)
print("user_info: ", user_info)
org_info = await get_spend_info(session, "organization", org_id)
print("org_info: ", org_info)
assert (
abs(key_info["info"]["spend"] - expected_spend) < TOLERANCE
), f"Key spend {key_info['info']['spend']} does not match expected {expected_spend}"
assert (
abs(user_info["user_info"]["spend"] - expected_spend) < TOLERANCE
), f"User spend {user_info['user_info']['spend']} does not match expected {expected_spend}"
assert (
abs(team_info["team_info"]["spend"] - expected_spend) < TOLERANCE
), f"Team spend {team_info['team_info']['spend']} does not match expected {expected_spend}"
assert (
abs(org_info["spend"] - expected_spend) < TOLERANCE
), f"Organization spend {org_info['spend']} does not match expected {expected_spend}"
@pytest.mark.asyncio
async def test_long_term_spend_accuracy_with_bursts():
"""
Test long-term spend accuracy with multiple bursts of requests:
1. Create org, team, user, and key
2. Burst 1: make requests, compute expected locally, verify proxy matches
3. Burst 2: make more requests, verify proxy total == burst1 + burst2
4. Verify total spend is consistent across all entities
"""
BURST_1_REQUESTS = 22
BURST_2_REQUESTS = 12
async with _make_test_session() as session:
await assert_proxy_healthy(session)
org_response = await create_organization(
session=session, organization_alias=f"test-org-{uuid.uuid4()}"
)
print("org_response: ", org_response)
org_id = org_response["organization_id"]
team_response = await create_team(session, org_id)
print("team_response: ", team_response)
team_id = team_response["team_id"]
user_response = await create_user(session, org_id)
print("user_response: ", user_response)
user_id = user_response["user_id"]
key_response = await generate_key(session, user_id, team_id)
print("key_response: ", key_response)
key = key_response["key"]
print(f"Starting first burst of {BURST_1_REQUESTS} requests...")
burst_1_responses = []
for i in range(BURST_1_REQUESTS):
response = await chat_completion(session, key)
burst_1_responses.append(response)
print(f"Burst 1 - Request {i + 1}/{BURST_1_REQUESTS} completed")
burst_1_expected = compute_expected_spend(burst_1_responses)
assert burst_1_expected > 0, (
f"Burst 1 expected spend is {burst_1_expected}. "
f"Usage: {[r.usage.model_dump() for r in burst_1_responses]}"
)
print(f"Burst 1 expected spend: {burst_1_expected}")
final_burst_1 = await poll_key_spend_until(session, key, burst_1_expected)
if abs(final_burst_1 - burst_1_expected) >= TOLERANCE:
await fail_with_diagnostics(
session,
stage="test_long_term_spend_accuracy burst 1",
expected=burst_1_expected,
observed=final_burst_1,
)
print(f"Starting second burst of {BURST_2_REQUESTS} requests...")
burst_2_responses = []
for i in range(BURST_2_REQUESTS):
response = await chat_completion(session, key)
burst_2_responses.append(response)
print(f"Burst 2 - Request {i + 1}/{BURST_2_REQUESTS} completed")
total_expected = burst_1_expected + compute_expected_spend(burst_2_responses)
print(f"Total expected spend (burst 1 + burst 2): {total_expected}")
final_total = await poll_key_spend_until(session, key, total_expected)
if abs(final_total - total_expected) >= TOLERANCE:
await fail_with_diagnostics(
session,
stage="test_long_term_spend_accuracy total",
expected=total_expected,
observed=final_total,
)
await asyncio.sleep(5)
key_info = await get_spend_info(session, "key", key)
team_info = await get_spend_info(session, "team", team_id)
user_info = await get_spend_info(session, "user", user_id)
org_info = await get_spend_info(session, "organization", org_id)
print(f"Final key spend: {key_info['info']['spend']}")
print(f"Final team spend: {team_info['team_info']['spend']}")
print(f"Final user spend: {user_info['user_info']['spend']}")
print(f"Final org spend: {org_info['spend']}")
assert (
abs(key_info["info"]["spend"] - total_expected) < TOLERANCE
), f"Key spend {key_info['info']['spend']} does not match expected {total_expected}"
assert (
abs(user_info["user_info"]["spend"] - total_expected) < TOLERANCE
), f"User spend {user_info['user_info']['spend']} does not match expected {total_expected}"
assert (
abs(team_info["team_info"]["spend"] - total_expected) < TOLERANCE
), f"Team spend {team_info['team_info']['spend']} does not match expected {total_expected}"
assert (
abs(org_info["spend"] - total_expected) < TOLERANCE
), f"Organization spend {org_info['spend']} does not match expected {total_expected}"